Free Pascal linking (Developers)
> Is the internal linker used for the go32v2 target too? Or does this target
> rely on ld.exe?
External linker still. I see the internal linker there, but it is commented. So probably sb tried quickly, but it didn't work without additional debugging/work.
> Btw: It's annoying that go32v2 executables become so much larger than in
> FPC 1.x. Why do stripped EXEs still contain strings from "$undefined" to
> "TResourceManager"? That are >12,500 bytes. "Hello world" in ~124K seems
> quite heavy anyway.
No idea, and no dos maintainer to ask. win32 ones are 20k, but the internal linker strips/smartlinks better because it "knows" pascal.
While FPC doesn't like unnecessary bloat, functionality goes over size. So a few kb aren't considered a problem.
However if you have an analysis why this happens, bugreport it, maybe there is something that can be done about it easily. It could be that the 2.0 branch for Dos was never fully analysed for these kind of issues.
While you are at it, debugging the internal linker might also save some space!
Complete thread:
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - DOS386, 04.03.2008, 02:07 (Developers)
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 04.03.2008, 05:08
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - DOS386, 09.03.2008, 02:11
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 09.03.2008, 09:40
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - DOS386, 09.03.2008, 02:11
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Japheth, 04.03.2008, 09:38
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - rr, 04.03.2008, 10:02
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 04.03.2008, 14:53
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Japheth, 04.03.2008, 18:32
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 04.03.2008, 18:57
- No cheats please! - Japheth, 05.03.2008, 11:02
- No cheats please! - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 14:07
- No cheats please! - Japheth, 05.03.2008, 11:02
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 04.03.2008, 18:57
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Japheth, 04.03.2008, 18:32
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 04.03.2008, 20:41
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 01:11
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 05.03.2008, 02:05
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - rr, 05.03.2008, 09:57
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - rr, 05.03.2008, 10:01
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 05.03.2008, 02:05
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 01:11
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | evil TCC - DOS386, 09.03.2008, 02:17
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | evil TCC - Japheth, 09.03.2008, 08:41
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | evil TCC - rr, 09.03.2008, 22:20
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | evil TCC - Rugxulo, 10.03.2008, 03:29
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:30
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 07.04.2008, 23:57
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - marcov, 15.04.2008, 10:43
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 25.07.2008, 06:55
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 25.07.2008, 23:15
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 26.07.2008, 00:27
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 25.07.2008, 23:15
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 25.07.2008, 06:55
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - marcov, 15.04.2008, 10:43
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 07.04.2008, 23:57
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 04.03.2008, 14:53
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Khusraw, 04.03.2008, 21:51
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 01:06
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 05.03.2008, 01:50
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Khusraw, 05.03.2008, 08:01
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 14:04
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Khusraw, 05.03.2008, 15:46
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 06.03.2008, 04:40
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Japheth, 06.03.2008, 07:52
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - tom, 08.03.2008, 21:50
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 09.03.2008, 00:53
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 09.03.2008, 09:36
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - tom, 10.03.2008, 12:59
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 09.03.2008, 00:53
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - DOS386, 09.03.2008, 03:02
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:39
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - Rugxulo, 08.04.2008, 00:09
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - marcov, 08.04.2008, 14:34
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - Rugxulo, 08.04.2008, 16:13
- Free Pascal linking - rr, 09.04.2008, 11:40
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 10.04.2008, 10:40
- Free Pascal linking - rr, 10.04.2008, 12:18
- Free Pascal linking - Rugxulo, 11.04.2008, 06:32
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 11.04.2008, 14:20
- Free Pascal linking - Rugxulo, 11.04.2008, 16:16
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 11.04.2008, 20:14
- compression / size wars - Rugxulo, 12.04.2008, 01:13
- compression / size wars - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:49
- compression / size wars - Rugxulo, 01.05.2008, 05:32
- FAT OGG - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 05:44
- compression / size wars - Rugxulo, 01.05.2008, 05:32
- compression / size wars - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:49
- compression / size wars - Rugxulo, 12.04.2008, 01:13
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 11.04.2008, 20:14
- Free Pascal linking - Japheth, 11.04.2008, 16:39
- Free Pascal linking - Steve, 12.04.2008, 05:19
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 12.04.2008, 14:41
- Free Pascal linking - Steve, 12.04.2008, 16:09
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 13.04.2008, 23:42
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 06:27
- Compression - marcov, 14.04.2008, 11:03
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 13:32
- Compression - Rugxulo, 14.04.2008, 20:00
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 20:16
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 10:40
- Compression - Steve, 15.04.2008, 12:24
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 15:43
- Compression - Steve, 16.04.2008, 11:32
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 15:43
- Compression - Steve, 15.04.2008, 12:24
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 10:40
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 20:16
- Compression - Rugxulo, 14.04.2008, 20:00
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 13:32
- Compression - Rugxulo, 14.04.2008, 19:55
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 20:44
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 09:59
- Compression - Steve, 15.04.2008, 11:55
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 15:24
- Compression - Rugxulo, 16.04.2008, 01:13
- Compression - Steve, 16.04.2008, 10:54
- Compression - marcov, 16.04.2008, 16:24
- Compression - Steve, 16.04.2008, 21:27
- Compression - marcov, 16.04.2008, 23:38
- Compression - Steve, 17.04.2008, 12:10
- Compression - marcov, 16.04.2008, 23:38
- Compression - Steve, 16.04.2008, 21:27
- Compression - marcov, 16.04.2008, 16:24
- Compression - marcov, 15.04.2008, 15:24
- Compression - Steve, 15.04.2008, 11:55
- Compression - marcov, 14.04.2008, 11:03
- Compression - Steve, 14.04.2008, 06:27
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 13.04.2008, 23:42
- Free Pascal linking - Steve, 12.04.2008, 16:09
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 12.04.2008, 14:41
- Free Pascal linking - Rugxulo, 11.04.2008, 16:16
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 11.04.2008, 14:20
- Free Pascal linking - marcov, 10.04.2008, 10:40
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - marcov, 08.04.2008, 14:34
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - Rugxulo, 08.04.2008, 00:09
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread | WC 1.52 - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:39
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - tom, 08.03.2008, 21:50
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Khusraw, 06.03.2008, 10:41
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Japheth, 06.03.2008, 07:52
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 06.03.2008, 04:40
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Khusraw, 05.03.2008, 15:46
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 14:04
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Rugxulo, 05.03.2008, 01:06
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 09.03.2008, 02:49
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Japheth, 09.03.2008, 08:56
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 09.03.2008, 12:40
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Japheth, 10.03.2008, 09:04
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 10.03.2008, 13:52
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - Japheth, 10.03.2008, 14:43
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - Steve, 11.03.2008, 10:17
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:44
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - Steve, 08.04.2008, 01:43
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - marcov, 08.04.2008, 14:36
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - Steve, 08.04.2008, 01:43
- Ich nix verstehen - andere Baustelle! - Japheth, 10.03.2008, 14:43
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 10.03.2008, 13:52
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Japheth, 10.03.2008, 09:04
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - rr, 09.03.2008, 22:10
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 10.03.2008, 03:39
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 10.03.2008, 09:08
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - rr, 10.03.2008, 12:31
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | DELTREE - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:32
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | DELTREE - rr, 02.05.2008, 16:20
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | DELTREE - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:32
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - rr, 10.03.2008, 12:31
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 10.03.2008, 06:24
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 11:39
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 10.03.2008, 12:07
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 10.03.2008, 13:58
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 05:30
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 02.05.2008, 00:47
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - rr, 02.05.2008, 16:22
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 03.05.2008, 08:16
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - rr, 02.05.2008, 16:22
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 02.05.2008, 00:47
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 05:30
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 17:55
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 10.03.2008, 20:49
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 21:41
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:52
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 10.03.2008, 20:49
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 10.03.2008, 13:58
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Khusraw, 10.03.2008, 16:00
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 17:42
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Khusraw, 10.03.2008, 17:50
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 17:56
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:55
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 08.04.2008, 00:02
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Khusraw, 10.03.2008, 17:50
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - RayeR, 10.03.2008, 17:42
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 10.03.2008, 12:07
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 11.03.2008, 19:29
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 12.03.2008, 08:01
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 12.03.2008, 20:13
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 13.03.2008, 04:10
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | INTEL - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:43
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | INTEL - Steve, 02.05.2008, 00:51
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 12.03.2008, 20:13
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 07.04.2008, 14:58
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 07.04.2008, 23:38
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 10.04.2008, 10:22
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 11.04.2008, 06:27
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 11.04.2008, 20:18
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 11.04.2008, 06:27
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - marcov, 10.04.2008, 10:22
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Rugxulo, 07.04.2008, 23:38
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:41
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | the "scientific" facts ore out DW - Steve, 12.03.2008, 08:01
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | new facts ore out: OW TCC CC386 - DOS386, 01.05.2008, 04:30
- BIG "C" compiler cmp | new facts ore out: OW TCC CC386 - Rugxulo, 01.05.2008, 05:27
- BIG "C" compiler comparison thread - Steve, 04.03.2008, 05:08